Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Christie Manussier's avatar

Holy shirtballs...what a ride!

Okay, so, this is an immediate follow for Zac ~ it was an obvious READ when I saw that Charlotte Clymer had shared it, because I respect HER so much.

It makes me want to have a conversation WITH Zac, because I now have so many thoughts in my head spawned by this article, but also would leave me too intimidated because I'm clearly a word butcher and dolt by comparison.

This.

Writing.

Even divorced from the topic, just...THIS WRITING!!

Captures so much of where I am on AI as tool and danger and expression of tech bro narcissism, but also curing cancer and quickly doing the types of search that traditional "engines" were always trash at ~ like, let's just slow its roll and sort out WHAT we're doing and HOW and WHY before it's all just a fait acompli?

Anyway, will be sharing this further, because YOWZA!

Evans Hedges's avatar

I feel like one distinction that’s missed in the comparison to ads for e.g. electricity of yore is that there are two forms of advertising happening right now. On one hand you have the blog posts, interviews, twitter feeds, etc. of the heads of the labs who are playing one game, and then the actual marketing from the company playing another.

The target of Amodi and Altman’s approach (where things can only ever get bigger) is fully and deeply related to the Silicone Valley approach of big visions get capital, small solvable problems don’t. This article does mention that this game of marketing may be pointed at investors/regulators, and I think that’s true.

What’s missing is the other game, where OpenAI and Anthropic *are* actually fighting each other in practical marketing directed towards individuals, with the ads being things like “help me plan a workout” or “how do I change a tire”. This is exactly the kind of concrete scoped tasks the article argues they should be focusing on, “thinking smaller”.

My point here is that in the age of terminally online VC’s and investors living on twitter, you can’t conflate the two games and historically the first game was happening all the same, just there wasn’t a twitter to watch it play out.

14 more comments...

Ready for more?